4Models of Communications Strategy
Print/Broadcast/Internet/PR
(Copy sent to MN legislature,
House Speaker, Steve Sviggum and Senate President Roger Moe and others:
Roy Terwilliger, Larry Fitzgerald, John Marty, David Jennings, Otis
Courtney, Sarah Psick, Victor Moore, Tom Hanson)
The how's and why's and the "art" of public relations as communications strategy by level of individuals and events In terms of macro and micro negotiations for communications success in building the desired image/perception.
Key themes:
- "Communications as the Ultimate Exercise of Power"
- "Communications as a problem solving discipline"
- "No Teflon, even for the formidable."
- All three statements are by Robert L. Dilenschneider, From his book A Briefing for Leaders: Communications As The Ultimate Exercise of Power Former President and CEO of the world's largest PR firm: Hill and Knowlton Now: CEO of The Dilenschneider Group
The 47
Models
The 47 proven models
listed below will serve any organization or individuals within an organization,
or both, whether corporate, nonprofit, or for a political campaign.
The discussion must
center on that what best fits the organization as a whole, the organization,
and then in its parts: the Chairman,
the CEO, the COO, the various senior executives and middle management
managers, as well as all staff professionals, support staff, etc. If a political campaign, then the candidate and the candidateªs agenda
are the focus.
All 47 models provide
solid ground on which to build the communications strategies needed
to meet desired communications' goals, and fit (1) any company or company organization (and the individuals within them)
of any industry, from manufacturing to service to retail to entertainment
to sports, etc., (2) any political campaign, whether national,
state, or local, and (3) they fit any organization or entity (and the individuals within them)
in the realm of politics and society, be it the United Nations, an individual
country, conflict between nations, nation-wide, a state or city or county
within, etc. Whether for positive events, or to turn negative events positive,
these models will enable the development of positive relations, whether public (external, exogenous)
or private/in-house (internal,
endogenous).
1. John
D. Rockefeller I: Going from
the most hated man in America to the most loved man in America. After he retired and experienced a religious
conversion, he sought help in changing his public image. His PR consultant (not called PR then) developed
a plan: wear a wig in public
so as not to look like the bald grim reaper; give away dimes to gatherings
of kids at events to which the press and photographers were invited,
gave money to worth causes (always in front of the invited media), and
created philanthropy and private foundations for the purposes of doing
good. All was part of the message. All was geared to his public appearances. His image was completely reversed. This was the first of two events which launched
the industry known as "public relations," this one being at
the micro level.
2. GE's 50th
Anniversary: held world wide. Millions of light bulbs in major cities. Neither name of company (GE) nor inventor (Edison)
were mentioned, but they didn't have to be: all knew. Presidents and heads
of nations were enjoined in the anniversary celebration. This was the second of two events which launched
the industry known as "public relations," this one being at
the macro level.
3. Ronald
Reagan's vision strategy: Mike
Deaver met with a special group at the Blair House, across the street
from the White House, every Friday, to strategize the message they wanted
over the horizon of the next 100 days. They came up with messages for each day for the next 100 days,
and for each hour of the next two weeks, all of which were reviewed
every Friday. This was the best way they felt they could combat
the attacks and hostilities aimed at them in both print and broadcast
media, in order to give them an chance to influence their desired outcomes. This was the strategy that caused Reagan to be called "The
Great Communicator." The group articulated the vision Reagan had and then outlined the
steps they needed to take to sustain the vision, coordinating appearance
by various administration officials on the Sunday morning talk shows,
Sunday editorial pages, etc. Note: I recommend that all clients have at least a different major emphasis
each month.
4. George
Bush's visionless strategy: he
said "I'm not into the vision thing," and dismantled Reagan's
communications apparatus. His
Chief of Staff, John Sununu was so confident of their success, that
he said "we are so popular we could have a depression and still
win re-election." They paid dearly for not having a vision and
then for not strategizing getting the messages out that were part of
that vision.
5. Bill Clinton's first two years had information leaks all over. Once they settled down, developed administration wide messages
and established when they were to be coordinated, they tightened up
their process: no more leaks. Clinton keeps "motoring on" to get his message out there. He has more speech writers than any President in history and
he gives more speeches and presentations than any President before him. He was able to stay out in front of the Impeachment process,
using critically damning information about those "across the aisle",
as he took it before the public, and was able to win public support
and keep his office. He used his video taped deposition not to talk
to the judge or grand jury but rather to the public at large who he
knew would be watching it later on TV. Bill Gates did not, and Bill's performance was so bad that the
Judge decided nothing he or any of his people who would follow him could
be trusted or believed, and thus should be punished with a breakup,
despite the fact that the evidence he lists will be reversed on appeals. So, even when Microsoft wins, they have paid a high price for
not believing in nor having a communications strategy (something common
to the innocent, who don't understand why "truth will out"
is often not true).
6. Al
Gore stays ahead of the "event horizon" curve, having
been ahead of many of his colleagues and competitors in matters of the
environment, the Internet, and other areas, turning them into favorable
communication messages for himself and for his own agenda wish list.
7. Roger
Ailes, author of You Are The Message (he counseled George Bush in
his first successful presidential run but did not his second, as Bush's
advisors didn't feel they needed
any help until it was too late; again, they were very wrong). Ailes understands public role playing very well. He also coached Ronald Reagan in his successful
debate with Walter Mondale. His
book title sums its: You are the message. His key emphasis is on how to handle the press while
they're trying to hang you.
8. Robert
L. Dilenschneider, author
of A Briefing for Leaders: Communication
as the Ultimate Exercise of Power: briefing
method model. He gives us our
three most important quotes:
"Communications as the Ultimate
Exercise of Power"
"Communications as a problem solving
discipline"
"No Teflon, even for the formidable."
9. Or,
as Ben Padrow used to say,
"You cannot not communicate."
10. The model of event horizons, looking at
both near term and far term horizons of events that will affect the
organization, whether positive or negative, and communicate accordingly,
based on what is called "futures research."
11. The constituent engagement model. of congresspersons who return every weekend (an excellent example is, I believe, Wisconsin, where the constant repeated return and mingling with constitutes enabled
a Jewish Democrat in a Wasp Republican district to keep getting re-elected),
as discussed by Edwin H. Friedman.
12. The "mastermind" model of Andrew Carnegie: discussed
in detail in Napoleon Hill's books Think and Grow Rich and Succeed and
Grow Rich Through Persuasion, and in the Hill book with W. Clement Stone: Success Through a Positive Mental Attitude. The "mastermind" is the name for a collective group
one always turns to for advice and counsel. With an office at 9 West 57th as well as at 261 Madison Avenue,
in New York City, this is a function I used to provide executives. Indeed, the development of Presidents clubs is precisely to give
guys at the top a sounding board among other Presidents, to speak off
the record and get ideas for developing the kind of communications they
need to be successful with their organizations in both internal and
external communications. As posted (6-16-00) on the SpiritualityRx.com
web page, we read "We need to a faith community of friends to inspire,
challenge, tease, and call us to be all we can be without unduly embarrassing
us for being where we are now."
13. FAQ book model for use by key spokesperpsons, as they prepare for both formal interviews (planned), and informal
(all non-planned situations in which they are asked questions).
16. The perfect "presentation of self in
everyday life" (Goffman's term and book title) of Michael Jordan. Knowing he would be seen mostly in news shots
going to and from whatever arena in which he was playing, he always
made sure he was wearing his best suits. He knew his perception depended upon it and he knew the success
of his many ventures, especially advertising of products, depended upon
it as well. .
17. The 7
Habits of Highly Effective People (book title) of Stephen Covey (which spent 250 weeks on
the New York Times best-seller list, and which is still a best seller),
proposes focusing oneªs communications on oneªs circle of influence
(things/people one can influence) rather than oneªs circle of concern
(things one can do little about). The
7 habits are essentially about obtaining self-knowledge and control
if one is to effectively deal with others. Called common sense by others, Covey says Whatªs common sense
just isnªt common practice.
18. Use King Arthurªs Knights of the Round Table
approach: an internal approach
to gathering the leading heads without suggesting any one is the head
or inferior to another.
19. Use Katherine Grahamªs Nights of the Round
Table approach: gathering
those of different mind sets, parties, ideologies, societal sector (private/corporate,
public/governmnet) around a round table holding 12, in her home, and,
as publishers of the Washington Post, doing so to break down gthe barriers
of formality and self-importance, as she tried to provide an open communications
channels among those around the table, to make communication less transient
and more anchored.
Adapting
the above to create Corporate Models
20. Always remembering Peter L. Bergerªs famous
dictim about adaptation: Reality is Áof course,ª‹‹‹until further notice.
21. Corporate Tradition Book or booklet (and possibly
also a Video/DVD). Offer
them for sale on the web site. Before
all voices are silenced by age and death, prepare a set of questions
that play to the positives of the organization's tradition/values/myths,
and ask them of significant past and current leaders. Create an "US" approach, as opposed to an "us
vs. them" approach. Include
positive things said over the years by all of the media, including those
positive things said before from those who are now critical.
22. Get 3rd party spear carriers/water carriers: prominent businesspersons or government officials, columns or
lead stories in local/national/world newspapers and magazines.
23. "Damage
Control Rapid Responses" to events, controlled and uncontrolled, meeting lies or innuendoes with facts, and, where errors have been committed,
acknowledgement coupled with steps taken to correct and steps to take
to prevent repetition.
(1) The lies can't be allowed to go unchallenged. Any time a falsehood is made a response with the fact is then
added to wherever you keep them: web site, press releases, etc.
(2) Yet
you don't want to get defensive.
(3) In terms of particular chief executives who are
targeted, pose it as a non-issue;
not even mentioned; not honoring it with any kind of statement. Sticking strictly to the falsehood countered
by fact approach. No defense
of the traditional kind, either in terms of position, race, religion,
etc. (unless absolutely necessary, although the approach is to do all
that is possible to avoid having to do so.
24. Responding
to the reality that most organizations have crises (from Robert Landauer,
The Oregonian, 11-14-01, p. B7:
(1) Donªt
deny: denial of a problem is
the most rfrequent mistake, an often the biggest. Cover-ups donªt last. Press
and public react angrily to that form of deceit.
(2) Donªt
lie: you may never regain the
public-s faith if you do.
(3) Donªt
withhold nor give too much too soon: reveal information as a crisis emerges. Its OK to withhold comment until the pucture clears and
responses are decided. A bunker mentaility ¯ refusing to communicate -- invariably
works to your disadvantage.
(4) Donªt
react slowly: react fast. Gossip,
rumor, misinforatmion and specutlation travel farther, faster and in
more ways than ever before. The
thrive when not blunted by official news. Responses delivered ive by rankning officials carry mor weight
thatn press releases do.
(5) Donªt
play the blame game: place blame
where it belongs. Be first to
say youªre wrong when you are. Itªs
the policy most likely to earn trust or at lest reduce hostility.
25. Hold
backgrounders for media representatives who are straight with the
facts and information. Donªt
let rumors or suspicions build.
26. Use
selected printed materials: (1) "Tradition Book" and video/DVD to tell the story of the organization,
accomplishments and glory and significance. ; (2) "Tail Gate
Guide" for use by fans to celebrate, with advertisers limited to
those with products, services, stations, or publications that could
be used at a tail gate party.
27. Develop
materials for key members of the organization likely to be quizzed by
the media: (1) an FAQ book, and (2) a "How to deal with the media" pamphlet.
28. Use
the "Work Out" method of GE to get the message to all in the
organization, top to bottom: three
books to look at: one on Jack
Welch, one on GE, one on using the work out method.
29. Create
a weekly audio or video tape subscription service, which would be
mailed to fans each week, and which include both commentary and highlights
of the game, as well as the selected Viking Communication Strategy message
of the week.
30. Take
advantage of the INTERNET with an interactive, flexibly changing web
page:
(1) Use the 1-2-3-4 knock out
punch of reach of audience/exposure; richness of content (quantity and quality); affiliation for loyalty, and navigational control/influence (which is changing things faster than we can sometimes
comprehend, so why not create a parade rather than follow someone else's),
with interaction in ways that are still being explored and discovered.
(2) In
other words: Exploit the differences in communications channels by adapting to each
accordingly: the far-reach-here-for-a-moment-and-gone-just-as-fast-TV
and radio; sound-bite and highlight needs of TV, the extended debate
needs of talk radio, the reach and information richness of local newspapers,
the vast reach and lesser richness content format of national print
media, the excitable point needs of columnists (take the offensive and
turn controversies into positives, and the Internet, as noted above,
which brings three new dimensions/dynamics to the communications strategy
party: (1) transparency (all is open), (2) speed (blur), and (3) the 1-2-3-4 knock out punch noted above of reach, richness, affiliation,
and navigation.
(3) Have post-event interviews in live web-cast format, where callers can cal in to talk about the event, the industry/activity/sport,
or other format/purpose to be determined.
(4) Web Stream news conferences and game highlight
on the web site, so media, fans, etc., can hear from the organization's
key people, and talk about subjects close to their heart without having
to be edited to a too short piece or edited by media where the message
is considerably different from the unedited version.
(5) Maintain
an updated pamphlet, either
print or Email (latter is quicker, cheaper, easier) to provide any news
outlet that asks or fans who write in.
(6) The Web page can also create
the "perfect" periodic, easily changeable pamphlet to reflect
the Communications Strategy approach
being followed at the moment, as well as enable the providing of "examples"
of what is undermining and sabotaging the otherwise fine relationship
between the organization and the people.
(7) Use the medium to provide rapid responses
to negatives news/columns about the organization: Use parallel columns. In the
column to the left = falsehoods. Column
to the right = the facts, citing the source for each. Archival research would be prominently displayed,
and added to as new material is developed. When this is a sensitive issue, hold an on-line contest to see which visitor can find the most blatant
and obviously false statements, and award event tickets as prizes.
(8) Develop
an FAQ list, updated regularly
on the Internet site.
(9) Have
a chat room on the site. Chat rooms are what keep AOL the largest and
keeps customers from switching. Chat
rooms create repeat visitors, called stickiness.
(10) Use
an intranet for the organization
and its consultants, on which can be placed schedules, commentaries,
favorable media pieces, and provide navigational links to appropriate
information, sports, shopping, etc. sources (see layout of www.ceoexpress.com
(11) Develop streaming on the Internet
site of key communications pieces.
(12) Use
an extranet for vendors,
suppliers, and the media
31. Establish
on-line communities:
(1) One
such entity is Neighborhoods Online, sponsored by the Institute for
the Study of Civic Values. Run
by old associate of mine, Ed Schwartz. Web address is http://libertynet.org/community/phila/natl.html
(2) Ed
has also written a book called Net Activism: How Citizens Use the Internet. He writes about how to use the Internet to return political power
to the grassroots. You can do
the same with your project.
(3) Net
Gain : Expanding Markets Through Virtual Communities: Hagel and Armstrong make the case that business success in the very
near future will depend on using
the Internet to build not just relationships, but communities. They also discuss how noncommercial Web communities
could use content, chat, andbulletin boards to promote e-commerce. In our case, it is to promote acceptance of a new stadium
(4) Hosting Web Communities: Building Relationships,
Increasing Customer Loyalty, and Maintaining A Competitive Edge: Figallo shows the advantages businesses can gain from creating
or supporting online communities, plus what types of expectations are
unrealistic. He believes, for example, that creating online communities
is not a reasonable way to directly boost sales or provide a highly
profitable income stream. He does show, however, that it can offer major
corporate advantages in the same way that good public relations or other
indirect marketing activities do, which, again, is what we are advocating
here for the 49ers.
When
conflicts arise, internally or externally, use one or more frameworks
of conflict resolution
[These response frameworks are to be used deliberately
for advance planning, as well as for immediate rapid responses needed
in crisis or for the unexpected. These
14, in turn, are part of a larger piece by Jessen, both available upon
request.]
8
MACRO level models
32. Macro Conflict Resolution/Communication model #1: Masada: doomed to failure as it was loveless, so one
side committed group suicide before the other side could kill them.
33. Macro Conflict Resolution/Communication model #2: West Germany's evangelical academies: love
based communications leading to creating West Germany and later reunifying
with East Germany.
34. Macro Conflict Resolution/Communication model #3: the universal Helsinki
Accords: upholding basic
human rights, the Achillesª heel of the totalitarian state.
35. Macro Conflict Resolution/Communication model #4: Visions, Strategies, and Realities
of/for the Future: a love
based approach to end apartheid in South Africa in order to achieve
elections based on majority rule.
36. Macro Conflict Resolution/Communication model #5: Middle East Oslo Accords: doomed to failure, as love less, based on hatred
and broken promises; on its way to being a "Masada"
37. Macro Conflict Resolution/Communication model #6: The Politics
of Love, of Michael Cassidy.
38. Macro Conflict Resolution/Communication
model #7: the third track
diplomacy contributions and structures of the Roman Catholic Church, especially in Mozambique, Central and South America, and South Korea
39. Macro Conflict Resolution/Communication
model #8: putting top
representatives of conflicting organizations in the anchoring environment
of a round table, as was used by Katherine Graham, Publisher of The
Washington Post, to foster open communications where suspicioned communications
existed before.
8
MICRO level models
40. Micro Conflict Resolution/Communication model #1: Movement toward collaboration, compiled by Peter Jessen, based on Ken Thomas.
41. Micro Conflict Resolution/Communication model #2: empower people to be responsible
model of Mary Pipher.
42. Micro Conflict Resolution/Communication model #3: keep people geared to overcome adversity through the CO2RE and LEADing formulas of Paul Stoltz.
43. Micro Conflict Resolution/Communication model #4: Managing conflict for individual and team success, by Sam
Imperati and JoAnn Houck.
44. Micro Conflict Resolution/Communication model #5: Serve others, as admonished by both Jesus and the Buddha. Albert Schweitzer: I donª
know what you will do in life, but I do know you wonªt be happy until
you learn to serve.
45. Micro Conflict Resolution/Communication model #6: Love each other, as admonished by both Jesus and the Buddha. Hannah Arendt says the human condition requires forgiving others,
as words and deeds are irreversible, and keeping promises, as that keeps
chaos at bay.
46. Micro Conflict Resolution/Communication model #7: Lists/Recipes for empowering both sides to achieve success, compiled
by Peter J. Jessen. As human
beings have no instincts for social interaction (Berger's phrase), they
"create instinct substitutes" (Gehlen's phrase). They create habits. These habits are said to follow the recipes
needed for success. People seek
"recipe knowledge" (Schutz's phrase). Model #5 contains over 30 pages of lists/recipes for success for all occasions, macro and micro.
47. Micro Conflict Resolution/Communication
model #8: putting top
conflicting members of the same organization together in an anchoring
environment of a round table, as was used by King Author for his Knights
of the Round Table, to get team members not acting as as a team to act
as a team again.